Whistleblower Protection platform largely welcomes EU agreement
Members of the WhistleblowerProtection.EU platform mainly welcomed the provisional agreement reached by the European Parliament and the Council, in the early hours of the 12th of March. Members celebrated victory in the final battle on reporting channels, which they had lobbied hard for in recent weeks.
The fact that the EU’s whistleblower protection package now leans heavily towards the European Parliament's proposals, which offer whistleblowers strong protection from facing reprisals, being fired or demoted, has been warmly applauded by platform members. The removal of internal mandatory reporting from the text, which the platform has lobbied hard for in recent weeks, is also being celebrated.
Commenting on today’s momentous whistleblower protection agreement, Nick Aiossa, Senior Policy Officer at Transparency International EU said: ‘Today is a historic day for those who wish to expose corruption and wrongdoing. Whistleblowers in the EU, like Howard Wilkinson, the Danske Bank whistleblower, have spent far too long facing unjust retaliation for speaking out. It is quite an accomplishment that negotiations between the institutions have come to a positive end.’
The removal of internal mandatory reporting from the text, which the platform lobbied hard for in recent weeks, is being celebrated.
Martin Jefflén, President of Eurocadres in welcoming the agreement said: ‘We have worked hard to remove the bad idea to require reporting to the employer before to a competent authority. We are very pleased this is now gone.'
According to platform member, Blueprint for Free Speech: ‘We are celebrating a major success - the EU has agreed legislation to give greater protections to whistleblowers across Europe! A huge thank you to all those who took action.’
The EU has agreed legislation to give greater protections to whistleblowers across Europe! A huge thank you to all those who took action.
Following the late-night agreement, the European Parliament’s whistleblower protection Rapporteur MEP Virginie Rozière, who led negotiations on the file said: ‘This text was one of my biggest priorities as an MEP and I am glad to see it succeed. We have had to fight to get a final text that meets expectations: whistle-blowers must be protected, whilst choosing the best means to be heard and to defend the interests of the citizens.’
Commenting on advocacy efforts, WeMove.EU said that, ‘Europe's Whistleblower Directive is a breakthrough for whistleblowers across the continent - and the quarter of a million petition signatures definitely helped.’
Europe's Whistleblower Directive is a breakthrough for whistleblowers across the continent - and the quarter of a million petition signatures definitely helped.’
However, in a somewhat dissenting comment, Ricardo Gutierrez, General Secretary of IFJ stated: While we welcome the agreement overall. We deeply regret that whistleblowers reporting directly to the media will only benefit from protection under restrictive conditions. We would have preferred them to be protected regardless of the channel used to issue the alert.’
Jefflén notes that, 'the final text is still being prepared and the complete package needs to be fully assessed, before we can make a full analysis.'
Timetable for the next few days:
Hopefully the final text will be ready, possibly by noon, latest in the evening.
COREPER II, the Council permanent representatives agree to the text.
JURI, the Legal affairs committee of the European Parliament agrees to the text.
Indicative date for the plenary vote in the European Parliament.
Follow www.whistleblowerprotection.eu and the twitter account @EUwhistleblower for updates.
The directive must be changed to that whistleblowers can report not only a special internal whistleblowing channel, but also to managers or law enforcement.
In an open letter 81 signing organisations urge the EU Council to adopt the Parliament’s position on reporting channels. The whistleblower protection directive is currently in trilogue. The signatories express serious concerns about the reporting channels regime in the Council and Commission positions in these negotiations.
A few weeks left to improve the whistleblower protection directive. Make your voice heard and sign the new petition for strong whistleblower protection!
The Romanian Presidency will play a key role is securing a robust whistleblower protection Directive, argues R. Nicolae, of Syene. He believes that Romania has a number of strengths which will support it leading the negotiations, as the whistleblower protection file moves from the Council to trilogue.
According to the Legal Counsel of the Danske Bank Whistleblower, S. Kohn, the Howard Wilkinson case clearly demonstrates that the EU Whistleblower Directive urgently needs to be revised to protect the right to report directly to law enforcement agencies and regulatory authorities.
The Duty Speech Loophole: how the EU Whistleblower Directive could backfire against its own objectives
Tom Devine, Legal Director of GAP explains why a series of technical contradictions within the EU draft directive need to be resolved, or the legislation could backfire and actually work against whistleblowers.
Council legal opinion must not be used to delay completion of whistleblower protection legislation
/ Blog The European Council must ensure EU delivers on its promise to whistleblowers The European Council has a responsibility to protect…
European institutions have been seen as being too close to lobbyists and vested interests. It would be a real shame if member states’ representatives were now seen as acting against public concerns, in resisting a whistleblower protection law which encourages the reporting of crime and wrongdoing, said Virginie Rozière MEP.